Note: Your instructor may choose to employ different standards; material she/he provides you with overrides this document.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Abstract |
A concise, well-written summary of project; includes all components needed in an abstract |
A written summary of project; includes all components needed in an abstract; but is unnecessarily wordy |
A written summary of project, but is missing one of the components needed in an abstract |
A written summary of project, but is missing two of the components needed in an abstract |
A written summary of project, but is missing three or more of the components needed in an abstract |
|
Introduction |
Demonstrates why research is of interest/ important to reader; is concise and well written |
Demonstrates why research is of interest/ important to reader; but needlessly wordy |
Explains research, but not why it is of interest to reader |
Provides some information on research |
Little information provided on the research is given |
|
Methods |
Easily followed explanation of procedure; not written as steps; materials included in methods |
Written as steps or materials were done in a list, but all information is there and understandable |
Some information is missing, or listed as steps and materials in list |
Procedure is confusing, but probably repeatable |
Procedure is not repeatable based on information given |
|
Results |
A concise and well-written synopsis of the results; includes a statement encapsulating each result from a Table/graph that clearly summarize the data gathered during the experiment. |
A concise and well-written synopsis of the results; includes a few statements encapsulating some results from a Table/graph that clearly summarize the data gathered during the experiment |
A written synopsis of the results; includes a few statements encapsulating some results from a Table/graph that summarize the data gathered during the experiment |
A written synopsis of the results; includes statements about results found in the Table/graph that summarize the data gathered during the experiment |
A written synopsis of the results; includes statements about results found in the Table/graph; table and/or graph does not clearly summarize results |
|
Discussion |
Clearly and rationally
interprets results/data in relation to research question. Use of data as
evidence to address question(s) is clear. Significance of results in relation
to current scientific understanding apparent. Accuracy and/or reproducibility
of data is also discussed. |
Interprets results/data in
relation to research question. Use of data as evidence to address question(s)
is clear. Significance of results in relation to current scientific
understanding may not be apparent or accuracy and/or reproducibility of data
is not discussed. |
Interprets results/data in
relation to research question. Use of data as evidence to address question(s)
is not clear. Significance of results in relation to current scientific
understanding may not be apparent or accuracy and/or reproducibility of data
is not discussed. |
Interpretation of
results/data is not related to research question. Use of data as evidence to
address question(s) is not clear. Significance of results in relation to
current scientific understanding is not apparent or Accuracy and/or
reproducibility of data is not discussed. |
Interpretation of
results/data is not related to research question. No use of data as evidence
to address question(s). Significance of results in relation to current
scientific understanding is not apparent and accuracy and/or reproducibility
of data is not discussed. |
|
Conclusion |
A succinct conclusion based on data, mechanism and question |
Conclusion based on data, mechanism and question, but is too wordy |
Conclusion based on data, but mechanism and/or question not mentioned |
Conclusion is not based on data, mechanism and/or question may be mentioned |
Conclusion is irrelevant to project |
Abstract Ð Comes first in your report, but is the last part written. It is a one paragraph summary of everything. It needs to include: an introductory statement, a purpose statement, your hypothesis, key results, and a conclusion (assessment of hypothesis).
Introduction Ð Tell the reader what he/she will need to know in order to understand the report. A short description of photosynthesis (at least Photosystem II) would be helpful. The reader should also know what DCPIP does (no, turning from blue to clear is not THE answer) and how DCMU (Diuron) works.
Methods Ð A written summary of what you did and what you used. DO NOT use a list for either your method or your materials. Make it flow. DonÕt get wordy. When youÕre finished, your roommate (or mom, or dadÉ) should be able to reproduce what you did.
Results Ð You should include a table of your data, and appropriate graph(s). It should be a well-written summary of your results. You should have a statement (but not necessarily a sentence) for each result. For example: ÒThe amount of glucose in the flask at the end of the Glycolysis/Fermentation procedure was lower (ÒblueÓ result from BenedictÕs test) than the amount of glucose in the flask at the beginning (ÒredÓ result from BenedictÕs test). See Table #Ó
Discussion Ð This is the Òmeat and potatoesÓ of your lab report; stay focused. Here you will need to:
- Answer your research question(s)/hypotheses with respect to your results
- Use your results to support your answers
- Discuss your findings in relation to what is currently known/accepted on the
subject
- When relevant, identify possible sources of error and how these might have compromised your findings
- Provide other possible ways to address/test questions that remain unanswered from your project/report
Conclusion Ð This is just a brief summary of your project based on your hypotheses/questions and your data. Remember, you wonÕt ÒproveÓ anything is true. In this particular report you wonÕt even be able to ÒproveÓ something is not true. You might ÒshowÓ, ÒdemonstrateÓ, or Òaccept.Ó If you have only ÒsupportedÓ or produced findings Òconsistent withÓ, these gradations are important; be clear on what your work accomplished and communicate it accurately.